If you are comparing Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations, you may be looking for the right mix of VAT support, bookkeeping, payroll, and ongoing tax advice. These accountancy firms are well-known in the UK market. However, choosing the right accounting support depends on your business stage, industry, and how much personalised guidance you need.
For many freelancers, contractors, and limited companies, it is important to know whether the service offers the right level of support. Having the right service can keep your business compliant with HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) and Companies House while helping you make tax-efficient decisions.
This blog compares the key features of Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations and explains what business owners should look for when choosing an accountant.
Get in touch with our skilled professionals for expert UK tax and accounting solutions specialised to minimise your tax burden and resolve your financial challenges efficiently.
Crunch Accounting Review
Crunch combines cloud accounting software with accounting and tax services for freelancers, contractors and small businesses.
This service is suitable for freelancers, sole traders, micro limited companies, and businesses wanting a digital-first accounting platform. However, the level of accountant access can vary by package. Also, businesses with more complex tax planning needs may require additional support.
Although Crunch’s packages look modern, businesses with more complex tax affairs may require more personalised advice than an automated platform alone can provide.
Gorilla Accounting Review
To make an informed choice, it is essential to break down Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations. Gorilla Accounting is a traditional firm, specialised in FreeAgent and Xero. It focuses heavily on contractor accounting and limited company compliance.
This accounting platform is suitable for IT contractors, consultants, engineers, and limited company directors. However, its strongest area is contractor accounting rather than general business bookkeeping. If you are looking primarily for software tools, you may prefer a different approach.
Businesses that require bespoke reporting or different accounting software should confirm compatibility before choosing a provider.
1st Formations Accounting Review
When comparing Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations, it helps to consider whether you need ongoing accounting support, a payroll package, or basic company formation.
If you want a company formation agent, then 1st Formations can be a good option. It is a company formation/registration agent that excels at basic paperwork but does not provide ongoing accounting.
1st Formations is suitable for new entrepreneurs, start-ups, and businesses needing a registered office address. Keep in mind that it does not provide ongoing bookkeeping, payroll, or VAT management. You will still need an accountant after incorporation.
Why Do Business Owners Compare Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations?
Business owners usually compare different accounting platforms such as Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations. This is done because each provider focuses on a different part of running a company. The right choice depends on whether the priority is company formation, VAT compliance, payroll, ongoing tax advice, or bookkeeping.
Each provider focuses on a different area. For instance, Crunch focuses on online accounting software and bookkeeping support. Gorilla Accounting’s main focus is
contractor and limited company accounting. Whereas 1st Formations specialises in company formation/registration and offers registered office services.
Look at the table below for a quick comparison of features of Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations:
| Feature | Crunch | Gorilla Accounting | 1st Formations |
| Bookkeeping | Yes | Yes | No |
| VAT returns | Yes | Yes | No |
| Payroll | Yes | Yes | No |
| Company formation | Yes | Limited | Yes |
| IR35 support | Basic | Specialist | No |
| Dedicated accountant | Varies by package | Yes | No |
| Best suited for | Freelancers & small businesses | Contractors & consultants | New company setup |
What are the Limitations of the Standard Options?
While exploring Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations, it is important to look beyond the initial onboarding costs and consider the quality of advice and the level of ongoing support. Some of the common issues with these standard providers are:
The Integration Gap
1st Formations is a company formation agent. This means it only helps you in company formation and not in accounting. They register your business with Companies House.
Once they help you register, their job is done, and you are left with the burden of accounting. You will have to arrange ongoing accounting support, migrate your data, and set up payroll and taxes with HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) yourself.
Rigid Software Ecosystem
The lack of software flexibility is a crucial issue to consider when discussing Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations.
Both Gorilla and Crunch force your business into their existing technical frameworks. Gorilla primarily builds its service around FreeAgent, whereas Crunch centres its service around its own accounting platform.
Automated Support vs. Real Advice
Crunch uses automation and software algorithms to keep its entry-level packages affordable. Gorilla uses a more traditional model, but the advice you get may still depend on the package and software provided.
Additionally, businesses with complex tax affairs may benefit from additional professional advice alongside accounting software.
Crunch vs Gorilla Accounting: Which is Better?
If you are wondering which accounting platform is better during the comparison of Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations, you should know that there is no single winner. Both Gorilla and Crunch cater to entirely different business needs and communication preferences.
Crunch can be a better choice if you are a freelancer or small limited company, want a lower-cost, tech-focused solution, and your bookkeeping and tax affairs are relatively simple.
In contrast, Gorilla can be a better option if you are a contractor affected by IR35, want more direct access to accountants, and your business needs personalised tax planning. Moreover, you should choose Gorilla if you prefer a more traditional accounting relationship rather than a software-first platform.
Gorilla Accounting vs 1st Formations? Which is Better?
The answer is quite simple. If your business needs ongoing accounting, tax advice, payroll, VAT support, or IR35 guidance, then you should choose Gorilla. However, if you only need to set up a company quickly and cheaply, go with 1st Formations. Lastly, Pricing varies by provider, service level and business type, so it is worth requesting a personalised quote before making a decision.
All in all, regardless of which provider you choose, ensure they are regulated by an appropriate UK professional body (such as ICAEW, ACCA or AAT where applicable) or supervised for anti-money laundering purposes.
Speak to an Expert
Get in touch with our skilled professionals for expert UK tax and accounting solutions specialised to minimise your tax burden and resolve your financial challenges efficiently.
The Bottom Line
The Crunch vs Gorilla vs 1st Formations comparison highlights that these accounting platforms offer bookkeeping software, specialist contractor accounting, and company formation services, respectively.
Crunch focuses on digital accounting, 1st Formations specialises in incorporation, and Gorilla Accounting focuses on contractors. However, many businesses may eventually need more accounting support, including bookkeeping, tax planning, VAT, payroll, and ongoing compliance.
It is essential to choose an accountant who understands your business and provides personalised advice. Your business deserves more than a rigid corporate package and a standard software subscription.
Rather than using separate providers for company formation, bookkeeping and tax advice, many businesses prefer a single accountant who can provide ongoing support.
At AccountingFirms, you can look for a qualified accountant who can offer both easy-to-use technology and expert advice. We help you search, connect, and partner with the perfect certified accountant for your specific industry.
Moreover, we have limited company accountants, contractor accountants, and startup accountants who offer company formation services, payroll, VAT returns, remote bookkeeping, and online bookkeeping services.
So what are you waiting for? Enter your postcode and find the best accountant now!
Disclaimer: The information provided on AccountingFirms.co.uk is for informational purposes only and should not be considered as financial advice. Always consult with a professional accountant to ensure compliance with UK laws and regulations.
Join 5,000+ businesses comparing today